Sanibel’s Favorite Ice Cream Shop
All of Pinocchio’s handcrafted, award-winning ice creams, gelatos, sorbets, and frozen yogurts are prepared on site daily in small batches from the freshest and finest ingredients.
Get a free ice cream topping – PRINT coupon!
Some of their unique ice cream flavors include Dirty Sand Dollar, Sanibel Krunch, Purple Cow, Berrywinkle on Periwinkle, and Gator Stew. The world famous Sanibel Krunch ice cream is their own recipe with homemade vanilla ice cream and toasted coconut mixed with chocolate, gourmet mixed nuts, and a few other secret ingredients. The Dirty Sand Dollar is a caramel based ice cream with malted milk balls and chocolate flakes. Pinocchio’s also serves a variety of delicious sugar-free, fat-free, low fat, and low carbohydrate ice creams. Winner Best of the Islands 2016 for frozen yogurt, gelato, and ice cream. Read Pinocchio’s featured blog article – click here!
Pinocchio’s is located in the Seahorse Shopping Center.